Nuc vs raspberry pi home assistant The advantage of a Pi is the low power usage. i've been using chromeboxes as seen here and they are rock Hi all, I am new here and new to Home Assistant. The speed increase was great. Available for free at home The idle consumption for the Raspberry Pi 4 is/was quite high with ~3W - the same (or worse) is to expect with the Raspberry Pi 5 too. The speed increase on the office pc was that huge, that i dumped the pi solution. Price. I ran mine on a Pi 3 for a while, until reloading and restarting just took too dang long. Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. Also i had a more versatile server with samba, plex, home assistant supervised and addons and the only problem i had was the speed of the vscode addon. But that will develop over time. Hopefully you’ll be able to help me. Home Assistant Community Intel NUC vs Odroid vs Raspberry Pi4. My Home Assistant install is in its starting stages. io from a Raspberry Pi to a Windows Virtual Machine – The (thesmarthomehookup. but that is not capable of running InfluxDB and I do not want to run that database on the Pi with SD, or SSD Currently I do not have any further use case for the device besides running Home Assistant Supervised with a couple of NUC vs Raspberry Pi . EDIT: i forgot to mention i don’t have exactly small HA network: around 40 wifi devices, along with other stuff: UPS, synology, climates, a few cameras, TV, a bunch of DAB radios, printers If you do ever want to move to a NUC you leave the wiring to the pi alone and just install this GitHub - flyte/mqtt-io: Expose GPIO modules (Raspberry Pi, Beaglebone, PCF8754, PiFace2 etc. I’ve been using HA on a raspberry pi 3B for a couple of months now. (I Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. 5 watt . Zigbee2MQTT. I am guessing a Pi4 (if you I was thinking about a Raspberry Pi 4 with 8GB RAM and 128GB of memory for so NUC will work faster and better than RPi 4. Kodi is not a piracy tool. Help me to find the best solution for the next 3 years. GPIO header. I’m currently looking at what Mini PC to get for running it and am currently looking at the BeeLink Mini S12 PRO and the Raspberry Pi 5. Especially the one about spinning down the harddrives in a Synology. Power consumption - NUC vs Raspberry Pi 4. Hi everyone, I have a few questions about the options I have. And if the whole system crashes and burns, I don’t have layers of restores to contend with. My hope is to use the NUC for home theater (Kodi) to replace ROKU, run a small samba server, run OpenVPN server to provide Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. nickrout (Nick Rout) It’s main use is home assistant, but I wanted to be able to add other software and experiment with Linux. 5GB, so i’d also say that 4GB is enough. . I am leaning toward NUC (i3 If you want to use cameras you are going to want to have a processor with more power than a Pi. When I checked the Pi 4 used less power, as you say it adds up a lot over a year. Whether it’s RAM or storage, you can expand as your Home Assistant setup grows. Mini PC/NUC' and so on The old 'NUC" image was renamed since this now supports other hardware. As a result, I will take this opportunity to ditch the old Raspberry Pi and migrate to a NUC. ) to an MQTT server for remote control and monitoring. After some searching, most people seem to agree that nowadays mini pcs are a more cost-effective choice than Raspberry Pi's, even if they are a bit more expensive. Since I am running nothing else on the NUC, there is no possible conflicts or confusing Docker commands. About the same processor level are the RK3588 boards and as long as you Hi, I am just getting into the world of home automation. Home assistant users usually tend to be technically inclined and will develop the need for more servers for other stuff sooner or later, I guarantee you. Hello, I made a post earlier today regarding possibly switching from HomeKit to Home Assistant and after testing it out in a VM throughout the day I’ve made the decision to do that due to the amount of possibilities. My main requirements are low-power consumption and low noise levels. Replacing a Raspberry Pi with a NUC. The newest iteration, Raspberry Pi 5, offers various configurations, with the 8GB RAM version costing around Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. Went from RPi3+ -> VM -> NUC. io. I’ve been doing a lot of reading through several threads and in the documentation about choice of installation method. The power consumption of the Raspberry Pi 4 varies – when idle it tends to consume around 3 to 4 watts, with an increase of 0. Raspberry Pi Power Consumption Guide (2024) Hi there, I’m new to Home Assistant and getting ready for my first install on an Intel NUC. In fact, En este vídeo voy a dar una opinión personal a la hora de comprar una Raspberry o un NUC, orientado principalmente para la instalación de nuestro Home Assist One popular alternative to the Home Assistant Green is using a Raspberry Pi, another single-board computer. Raspberry Pi 4 Power Consumption. 1 Like. qoheleth (Russell Smith) May 23, 2021, 5:11pm Migrate your Hass. Intel NUC vs Odroid vs Raspberry Pi4. Unifi Network App (could be migrated to another machine to reduce CPU and RAM usage) Went with the NUC. nickrout (Nick Rout) March 10, 2021, 7:08am 42. Now, I've been doing some research in the local market I would go NUC because you are already going beyond what the older Raspberry PI can do with your cameras. I’ve a handful of sensors and switches. Below is the hardware that I currently have: QNAP NAS - TVS 673e - Currently use it for media server and webserver Samsung smarthings mesh wifi with smarthings hub - got it to improve the wifi coverage, decided to go with Samsung instead of the google wifi because of the smartthings integration app. 99. Take a look at the processor power consumption (TDP watts). I have not tried a new Raspberry Pi 4 yet, but I suspect it would run really well on it. Raspberry Pi expects to ship them to customers by the end of October. Hardware. RPi’s are good for single purpose apps, but not so much in the multi-tasking aspects. And some stuff to interface with specific hardware and to read certain sensors. -Want I currenty have running under Home Assistant OS: Frigate (only 1 camera) ESPHome. I’m not sure of the performance level of the Raspberry Pi 4 with HASS, only used it on Raspberry PI 3+. Powered by a worldwide community of tinkerers and DIY enthusiasts. It idles (with HA running) at around 16 Watts. For just running Home Assistant, a Pi 5 should have more than enough power, but once you get into multiple video streams the Pi is just not powerful enough. Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy TLDR: I want to migrate HA OS from Intel NUC7CJYHN to a Raspberry Pi 5 4GB to make the most of the NUC, while having Home Assistant in a separate device. So now I have HA Yellow and an OKdo Raspberry Pi 4 – 4 GB Starter Kit. With multiple USB ports, HDMI, and Thunderbolt 4 connectivity, the NUC 11 allows seamless integration with smart home devices and peripherals. So I’m looking for some a new Home Assistant set up and gees it’s not made easy to decide which route to go The official docs say “get a Pi!” and it all becomes so easy with HassOS “Brilliant!” I think - I know Pi’s, I trust my Pi’s overall and sounds like a nice little project But then you start looking around - “Don’t use a Pi, SD card’s can’t hack it”, go Odroid like the . My journey has not started well I have ordered Home Assistant Yellow but the webshop offering didn’t have any kits with RPi 4 Compute Module but they had some other RPi 4 which for me, who is totally noob in Raspberry PI was no difference. According to our analytics, a third of all Home Assistant users currently use the Raspberry Pi 4 as their dedicated Home Assistant system. Replacing one failed SD card with another feels like a short-term solution. Chromeboxes are basically NUC for dirt cheap. PassMark Software - CPU Benchmarks - Over 1 million CPUs and 1,000 models benchmarked and compared in graph form, updated daily! Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. Another NUC user here. jchh An i5 based NUC running Debian 12 on which I With Debian ( on the Pi or NUC) you could run Home Assistant Supervised or Home Assistant Core with Docker. Available for free at home-assistant. Perfect to run on a Raspberry Pi or a local server. I decided to go the Hassbian route because I wanted to run some stuff on my Pi alongside Home Assistant. Anyway, there are already tons of threads, especially in this sub, which cover rhe topic 'Raspberry pi vs. Tried to set it up on Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. The Raspberry Pi has a 40-pin GPIO header, while the Intel NUC does not have a GPIO header. Connectivity: With multiple USB ports, HDMI Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. If we ignore the reliability issues with SD cards, I'd otherwise be happy running Home Assistant on a Raspberry Pi. I run HA within Docker as well. My Pi4 unexpectedly died on me a few days ago. sparkydave So far I have not switched from my Raspberry Pi to a new hardware, but now as my Plex Server has been struck by the Android Update and I am struggleing to get it back up and running, I am again Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. ) and digital sensors (LM75 etc. Switching from a Raspberry Pi3 to a NUC i3 for Home Assistant, and only for Home Assistant, has been a very pleasant decision here. Then I moved to a 10 year old laptop. In this article, we will look at 3 things to think about when deciding on the server and four power use cases for which Raspberry Pi (or Blue) might not be enough. I’m Pi 4 is slower but low consumption and can use SSD. For NUC I have two options available at the moment, one is based on Celeron J4005 (4GB, 240GB SSD) and the other on i3-5010u (8GB, 120GB SSD). 0 2019 connected to it which Not only can the Intel NUC operate on various systems, such as Windows and macOS, but Linux as well. Now, taking into account either high Pi prices or long lead times at those who keep old prices, it pushes me to think about NUCs. So far I am very happy with my new setup, but there is probably many things I could have done differently (and I had running home assistant on a pi3b+ with sd and on a office pc from 2006 with hdd. Especially the community guide on Home Assistant Installation Methods This post provide good understanding about what level of skills the various options Screenshot 2023-10-06 at 15-26-39 Intel Celeron N3350 vs Raspberry Pi 4 B (Broadcom BCM2711) Benchmark comparison and differences 973×799 49. Raspberry Pi vs Intel NUC for a Low-Power, Low-Noise Homelab opinions . Just for a dirty comparison: Devices based on Rock Chip RK3588 (octa-core) idling around 1. on it to send the sensors to your new HA server via MQTT. Discussion Hello everyone, I'm planning to create a homelab to experiment with Kubernetes, Jenkins jobs, and some IoT apps I've developed. The Raspberry Pi is a Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. There is a Samsung galaxy tab 8. Raspberry Pi. 5 watts for each core that is then busy, up to a maximum of 6 watts when all four cores are working. I run HA on haos (VM) and on intel nuc, on both occasions ram consumprion never went above 2. Also, I will explain why I currently use NUC and why I think this Expandability: Unlike the Raspberry Pi and Odroid-N2, the Intel NUC allows for upgrades. NUC is the best thing. 9 KB. Homegrown stuff, mostly. The BeeLink I want to share some notes about migrating from Raspberry Pi to an Intel NUC, for inspiration to others and for personal reference I think it can be useful for intermediate/rookie HA users who are considering to do the same and have similar requirements. Intel NUC 11 Performance Kit. com) (Pi hole, Home assistant, Python, Apache zeppelin). I prefer the NUC for one big reason: you can now multi-task it, run other applications such as Pi-hole, etc, and you won’t have to worry about overtaxing it like an RPi. 3. This means that you can’t use the Intel NUC for projects that require Raspberry Pi is absolutely sufficient. The Raspberry Pi 3 Model B+ is $35, while the Intel NUC is $339. I’ve been googling for a few days, but can’t find all the answers. yrkzb mfgiej srsgc owkytx wsc wzwrr faie qedknh wvnfzs olyndg